No Matter Who Wins Today’s Elections, 45Q Will Survive. Here’s Why…
Author
Alexander M. Economides
Purpose
This article was written independently by Alexander M. Economides and originally published on LinkedIn on November 3, 2026, to coincide with the U.S. elections. It was developed to explain the political and economic forces supporting the continued survival of the federal 45Q carbon capture tax credit, building on earlier analysis of its bipartisan appeal. The article also examines why other energy incentives, particularly those supporting renewable electricity and clean hydrogen, face greater political opposition and proposes a technology-neutral approach to improving their durability.
Original Article
Americans are out voting today, but regardless of who wins the elections, I bet that 45Q, the federal carbon capture tax credit, survives. This is because neither party has much incentive to eliminate it, despite what many politicians may say publicly.
45Q has demonstrated remarkable political resilience. Created in 2008 under President George W. Bush, it survived Democratic and Republican administrations, including the Trump administration’s 2025 overhaul of clean-energy incentives. At the risk of sounding cynical, this is happening because, in the simplest terms, 45Q is urban blue areas paying rural red ones to pollute less. Its details may change slightly over time, but the underlying credit should have continued supporters on both sides of the aisle for years to come.
Democratic constituencies get actual emissions reductions. Republican constituencies, especially in industrial and hydrocarbon-producing regions, get investment, employment, and opportunities to keep existing industries operating. It is an unusually convenient political arrangement. Even politicians who dislike the very concept of subsidies have constituents who benefit from and therefore rely on this one.
There is another important feature: participation is voluntary. Carbon capture is expensive; requiring industrial facilities or fossil-fuel generators to capture their emissions would create formidable economic and political opposition. Offering a tax credit, instead, lets companies pursue capture where and, importantly, when the incentives justify the investment; if they cannot make the economics work, they do not have to participate.
That distinction matters. Rather than forcing a confrontation with established industries, 45Q simply encourages investments in lower-emission operations. This creates a constituency interested in preserving the policy, while avoiding creating constituencies that want to destroy it.
Why Wind and Solar Subsidies Are Different
Wind and solar face a different political problem. Their growth creates direct competition for conventional electricity generators, particularly natural-gas plants, and the terms of that competition often appear unfair.
In markets such as Texas, companies must bid to dispatch electricity based on their short-run marginal generation costs. Wind and solar have effectively zero marginal generation costs, while gas-fired plants must purchase fuel. Renewable generators therefore have a structural advantage in dispatch, regardless of whether their total costs, especially when you include the costs they impose on the broader electricity system, are lower. That advantage often artificially reduces conventional generator revenues.
The complete economics deserve their own article. But, for present purposes, the political consequence is enough: when people perceive (even if they are wrong) that a technology is unfairly benefitting from rules that disadvantage another industry, they are likely to create political push back. In other words, the resistance to wind and solar is not necessarily so simple as just ideological opposition to clean energy.
Could 45V Follow 45Q’s Example?
That brings us to 45V, the clean hydrogen production tax credit. Unlike 45Q, its future is much less secure. Legislation enacted in 2025 shortened the window for new projects to qualify by requiring construction to begin before 2028. Existing qualifying projects can still receive the credit, but the U.S. government is curtailing opportunities to develop new ones.
I suspect a future administration will try to revive 45V. But if the credit is to survive politically, it needs a broader constituency than the one its original regulatory framework cultivated. The solution, in my view, is technological neutrality. There is nothing fundamentally wrong with the U.S. government working to establish stringent lifecycle-emissions standards and requiring credible verification, but it should not be prescribing the specific method of hydrogen production. If produced hydrogen meets the emissions requirement, why should it matter whether it comes from electrolysis, natural gas with carbon capture, or some other process?
The Biden administration deliberately designed 45V’s electricity-sourcing rules to favor specific production pathways, making the credit extremely difficult to obtain through other means. Removing prescriptive restrictions while preserving emissions standards would give established energy producers more pathways to earn the credit and thus more reason to support it. Without that change, I expect 45V to fade away. With it, the credit could develop the sort of cross-party economic support that has protected 45Q.
My preferred approach to energy policy is straightforward: government should set the objective, define measurable performance standards, and make sure companies bear the costs they impose on others. But it should leave the engineering solutions up to engineers.
For 45Q, that political bargain is already working. Urban voters can support emissions reductions, rural and industrial communities can support investment, and neither party has much reason to tear up the arrangement.
Tags: 45Q, 45V, Carbon Capture, Hydrogen, Energy Policy, Tax Credits, Bipartisan Policy, Renewable Energy, Technology-Neutral Policy, Energy Economics